Blog

The best choice depends on your home’s fuel access, hot-water demand, and installation needs. This article contrasts gas tankless options with electric tankless systems and profiles five top gas models to help you decide who should buy gas versus electric. Gas tankless units are typically preferred where natural gas is readily available and continuous hot water is needed at higher flow rates. Electric models often suit homes with ample electrical capacity and lower simultaneous usage. Below you will find concise product insights, a quick buying guide, and answers to common buyer questions.

Quick product comparison

• Natural Gas Tankless Water Heater, 5.26 GPM Outdoor — Best for outdoor installation and mid-sized households.
• Rheem RTGH-84DVLP-3 — Indoor propane model with high efficiency; good for tight spaces.
• Rheem RTG Series 8.4 GPM Natural Gas Tankless (Outdoor) — High flow, outdoor use, strong for larger households.
• Rinnai RX160iN Condensing — Smart features, versatile installation (indoor/outdoor).
• Rheem RTG Series 7.0 GPM Natural Gas Tankless — Indoor installation, reliable continuous hot water.

Natural Gas Tankless Water Heater, 5.26 GPM Outdoor

Best for outdoor installs and mid-sized homes.

Selected for its outdoor compatibility, Fahrenheit digital display, and multi-protection features that help manage heat and safety. Use this when you want straightforward outdoor installation with reliable mid-range flow.

Caution: Outdoor units require weather protection and proper venting.

Best for indoor propane installations with higher efficiency and compact design.

Selected for its condensing technology and flexible venting options, which can save space and improve efficiency in tighter indoor spaces.

Caution: Propane models require proper venting and gas line sizing; ensure compatibility with existing systems.

Best for outdoor, high-demand households needing strong flow and outdoor resilience.

Selected for its outdoor placement and robust 8.4 GPM capacity, suitable for larger homes and high simultaneous demand.

Caution: Outdoor units require weather protection and proper clearance for venting and servicing.

Best for tech-forward buyers needing smart controls and flexible placement.

Selected for its Smart Sense compatibility and flexible indoor/outdoor installation, ideal for modern homes seeking space efficiency.

Caution: Condensing models require proper venting and condensate management; installation may be more complex.

Best for indoor use when space and gas line sizing are ideal for reliable daily hot water.

Selected for steady performance in indoor settings with a balanced flow for medium to larger households.

Caution: Indoor installation requires proper ventilation and clearance around the unit.

Buying Guide: Gas vs Electric Tankless

What should I consider when choosing gas vs electric?

Fuel availability is a primary driver. Gas units typically require gas service, venting, and appropriate clearance, while electric units need a strong electrical panel and may rely on higher electrical capacity to hit similar flow rates. Consider peak hot-water demand, climate, and the number of simultaneous hot-water draws in your home.

Flow rate and heating capacity

Tankless units are rated by gallons per minute (GPM). Match the unit’s GPM to your household needs. For higher simultaneous usage (showers, laundry, dishwasher), a higher GPM model is often necessary. Outdoor gas models can deliver strong flows with fewer space requirements when venting is straightforward.

Installation and space

Gas units generally require venting, gas lines, and a vent termination outside. Electric units need electrical wiring and potentially a dedicated circuit, which can influence the installation cost and complexity. Consider available space, ventilation, and weather exposure for outdoor gas units.

Efficiency and operating costs

Condensing gas models typically offer higher efficiency than non-condensing versions, translating to lower operating costs over time. Electric tankless heaters can vary in efficiency based on design and controller features, but electricity prices and upgrade costs influence total cost of ownership.

Durability and maintenance

Look for units with protective features such as digital displays, multiple protections, and access for routine maintenance. Condensing units may require condensate management and occasional professional servicing.

Which should you choose?

• Choose gas if you have reliable gas service, hot-water needs at higher flow, or venting is already available. Gas often provides faster hot-water delivery at a given GPM, especially in outdoor setups.
• Choose electric if you lack gas service, prefer easier electrical wiring, or require installation in spaces where venting is impractical or prohibited.

Quick tips for buyers

• Verify venting compatibility and clearance requirements for gas models.
• Assess electrical capacity before selecting an electric tankless model.
• Consider future household changes (adding bathrooms, upgrading appliances) that may affect hot-water demand.

FAQ

1. What is the main difference between gas and electric tankless heaters? – Gas heaters rely on gas fuel with venting and typically deliver higher flow at higher demands; electric heaters rely on electricity and may require substantial electrical capacity for the same flow.
2. Is a condensing gas tankless water heater worth it? – Condensing models use exhaust heat to improve efficiency, which can reduce operating costs over time.
3. Do I need venting for a gas tankless unit? – Yes, most gas tankless units require proper venting to expel combustion gases safely.
4. Can I install a tankless water heater indoors? – Gas units are often installed indoors with venting; some models are designed for indoor/outdoor use. Electric units are typically installed indoors, depending on space and electrical supply.
5. What size gas tankless should I choose? – Pick a unit with a GPM rating that matches your peak simultaneous hot-water demands, such as showers and appliances running at the same time.
6. Are electric tankless heaters more expensive to run? – Electricity prices vary; total cost depends on usage, efficiency, and local utility rates.